BMW M2 Years to Avoid (Best and Worst)

BMW M2 Years to Avoid – Are you considering the thrilling experience of owning a BMW M2? As a luxury sports car enthusiast, you’re probably already aware of the M2’s reputation for its dynamic performance and sleek design.

However, before you make a decision, it’s crucial to be well-informed about the model’s history to ensure you’re investing in the best possible version.

When searching for your dream car, it’s essential to have all the necessary information at your fingertips.

In the case of the BMW M2, certain model years have been associated with specific challenges that could impact your ownership experience.

BMW M2 Years to Avoid

While the BMW M2 is renowned for its performance and luxury, not all years are created equal.

Let’s explore the key factors to consider when evaluating BMW M2 model years, focusing on the years that might not offer the premium driving experience you’re seeking.

So, let’s get started and ensure your BMW M2 journey begins on the right track!

BMW M2 Years to Avoid

We understand that your investment in a BMW M2 is more than just a purchase—it’s a commitment to exhilarating drives and top-notch engineering.

We’ll break down the problematic years, highlighting the issues that have led to them being labeled as less desirable in the M2 lineup.

Our goal is to empower you with the knowledge you need to make an informed choice that aligns with your driving aspirations.

BMW M2 Years to Avoid

Let’s begin the exploration and ensure your BMW M2 experience is everything you’ve envisioned.

2016 BMW M2: Headlight Havoc

The year 2016 marked the introduction of the BMW M2, and while it promised thrilling performance, it wasn’t without its flaws. Owners of the 2016 BMW M2 reported a recurring issue with the exterior lighting system, particularly the headlights.

Some unfortunate drivers found themselves contending with headlights that flickered ominously or worse, failed completely during their drives.

This posed a severe safety hazard, as compromised visibility could lead to accidents, especially during nighttime or adverse weather conditions.

This issue extended to both low and high-beam headlights, creating a concerning pattern.

Official recall data supports the gravity of the situation, as BMW issued a recall for the 2016 M2 due to potential problems with the headlight control units.

For a vehicle marketed as a high-performance powerhouse, these lighting malfunctions were far from acceptable.

Ensuring the safety and confidence of their customers should be a top priority for BMW.

2017 BMW M2: A Year of Struggles

The year 2017 brought a new set of challenges to the BMW M2 lineup. While this model promised a continuation of the M2’s thrilling performance, it also introduced a range of issues that marred the experience for many owners.

Among the most troublesome problems were recurring complaints about the exterior lighting system. Reports indicated that certain lights failed to function entirely, posing risks both to the driver and other road users.

Another major concern centered around the instrument cluster and electrical system. This unfortunate combination resulted in drivers experiencing sudden and complete power loss—a nightmare scenario while navigating busy roads.

To address these issues, official recalls were necessary, a move that reflects the seriousness of the problems at hand.

2018 BMW M2: Shedding Light on Exterior Components

Moving on to the 2018 BMW M2, a crucial lesson emerges: never underestimate the importance of maintaining your exterior lighting and visibility/wiper components.

The allure of the M2’s performance might distract from seemingly minor issues, but neglecting key components can lead to significant inconveniences and safety risks.

Dim headlights can compromise your visibility, especially during low-light conditions, and faulty wiper blades can hinder your ability to maintain a clear view of the road.

Driving with impaired visibility isn’t just uncomfortable; it’s also dangerous for you and others on the road.

BMW M2 Best Years

For dedicated BMW enthusiasts, the quest for the perfect ride is an unending journey. The pursuit of speed, thrill, affordability, or even the potential for future classic status fuels this hunt.

Amidst the extensive BMW lineup, there is one model that has consistently garnered attention—the F87 M2.

Since its introduction in 2016, the BMW M2 has been hailed by numerous automotive journalists as one of the premier performance vehicles available, regardless of price.

BMW M2 Best Years

The Distinctive F87 M2 Legacy

The F87 M2, introduced in 2016, embraces a unique legacy within the BMW family. This performance-driven masterpiece was born from a historical recipe that combines the heftiest engine with the lightest frame—a formula borrowed from the muscle car era.

Inspiration was also drawn from BMW’s own legendary 2002 Turbo and 1M models.

Unlike its limited-production predecessors, the F87 M2 was mass-produced and offered in various configurations.

Although production of the F87 generation has ceased, the vibrant second-hand market continues to offer a multitude of deals. This accessibility, coupled with competitive prices, positions the F87 M2 as a savvy investment choice.

Understanding the Variants

Within the F87 M2 lineage, three distinct variants emerge, each catering to specific preferences and desires. The initial M2, powered by the N55 3.0-liter turbocharged six-cylinder engine, delivers 365 hp.

Enthusiasts have the option of a 6-speed manual or a 7-speed DCT gearbox—a choice that empowers drivers to experience the car’s performance to the fullest.

2018 witnessed the arrival of the M2 Competition, boasting the S55 twin-turbo six-cylinder engine sourced from the M3/M4 models.

With enhanced suspension, braking, and an output of 405 hp to the rear wheels, the M2 Competition takes performance to the next level.

A pinnacle moment arrived with the M2 CS, introduced a year later. This ultimate M2 edition housed a robust S55 engine generating a commanding 444 hp.

Accompanied by an aggressive design package and limited production of 2200 units, the M2 CS solidified its place as a collector’s delight.

Choosing Your F87 M2

Determining the ideal F87 M2 model year is a decision influenced by your intended use. For those considering an investment piece, the limited-run M2 Competition or M2 CS stand as enticing options.

Seek examples with minimal mileage and impeccable condition, as these will likely hold greater future value.

Navigating Modifications

Among BMW M2 owners, a penchant for customization is common. While some modifications—such as blacked-out grilles, wheel spacers, and splitters—are subtle and complementary, others venture into the realm of performance upgrades, body kits, and exhaust modifications.

If you’re considering a modified M2, proceed with caution.

The Nürburgring Connection

Many M2 owners are drawn to the track, utilizing their vehicles for weekend thrills. While the M2’s mechanics and suspension are well-suited for this purpose, it’s essential to assess the wear and tear such usage may have imposed on the vehicle.

Extensive track time might leave its marks, both visually and mechanically.

Addressing Known Issues

The F87 M2 stands out as a robust performer, with a few known issues that warrant attention. While major mechanical problems are rare, a few checks are prudent.

Coolant and oil leaks are manageable concerns that stem from components like the electric coolant pump and valve cover.

Manual and DCT transmissions characterize the M2. Manuals exhibit clutch pedal juddering in some cases, while DCTs remain reliable when stocked and properly maintained.

Problems such as overheating, unusual sounds, or gear slippage indicate abuse and should trigger caution.

BMW M2 Problems

The BMW M2, a symbol of automotive performance and elegance, has enthralled driving enthusiasts with its power and allure.

Yet, like any masterpiece, the BMW M2 isn’t immune to its share of challenges.

We delve deep into the realm of BMW M2 problems, shedding light on the common issues that owners may encounter.

We provide you with insights to navigate the complexities of M2 ownership.

BMW M2 Problems

1. Oil: A Perennial Predicament

Oil issues are an inherent theme in performance vehicles, and the BMW M2 is no exception. The intricate engine design involves numerous gaskets and rings that maintain critical seals between components, such as pistons and other engine parts.

Over time, elements like the rubber oil pan gasket and oil filter housing gaskets may succumb to wear, leading to gradual oil leaks or even oil burning.

The valve cover itself can contribute to this problem.

Complicating matters is the M2’s propensity to run at elevated temperatures, a characteristic shared with other BMW vehicles.

This elevated temperature can expedite the consumption and leakage of oil, often at a faster rate than typical sedans.

While specific complaints on platforms like may be limited, it’s noteworthy that performance vehicles often come equipped with an engine oil travel bag to accommodate the need for additional oil.

Read Also: Why Are BMWs Oil Changes So Expensive?

2. Water Pump Woes: The Heat Dilemma

The BMW M2’s impressive performance comes at a cost—elevated heat generation. Unfortunately, the very heat that powers its performance can undermine its cooling components.

Water pump issues are not uncommon, leading to gradual failure.

This poses a significant concern for a vehicle that already operates at elevated temperatures.

3. Coolant Challenges: A Dual Threat

In tandem with water pump vulnerabilities, the hoses responsible for circulating coolant are susceptible to leaks. Thankfully, unlike water pump issues, addressing coolant hose leaks is relatively more straightforward.

Most technicians can replace or repair these hoses with ease, mitigating the risks associated with cooling system inefficiencies.

4. Electric and Lighting Quirks

The BMW M2’s lighting system, while generally reliable, can exhibit perplexing behaviors. Drivers have reported instances where lights turn on and off unexpectedly or blink rapidly.

Some lights may remain illuminated without reason, such as turning signals or brake lights activating without driver engagement.

While not a common problem, these anomalies can be frustrating.

5. Balancing Performance and Comfort: Harsh Ride Complaints

A subjective matter, the BMW M2’s suspension has generated diverse opinions. Crafted to achieve high speeds and sharp turns, the suspension sacrifices the luxurious cushioning often associated with high-end vehicles.

Some users find the ride to be harsh and stiff, reflecting the inherent compromise between dynamic handling and ride comfort.

Acknowledging that comfort remains intact at lower speeds, it’s crucial to consider the compromise required in producing a performance-oriented vehicle.

What Goes Wrong with BMW M2?

Several issues can arise with the BMW M2’s Dual-Clutch Transmission (DCT). Drivers have reported experiencing shaking or shuddering, transmission overheating, and hesitation or delayed shifting.

These problems can impact the overall driving experience and may require attention to maintain optimal performance.

Are BMW M2s Reliable?

The original BMW M2 has garnered a reputation for reliability. However, there are a few common concerns that owners might encounter. One issue involves the valvetronic system, which can deteriorate over time.

Interestingly, some anomalies have been observed where even brand-new cars experience Valvetronic system failures, potentially due to break-in metals clogging the oil squirters.

Is BMW M2 a Good Investment?

The BMW M2 presents itself as a compelling investment option, particularly for enthusiasts seeking a high-performance driving experience. While not a budget-friendly choice, its price aligns with competitors like the Audi TT RS and Porsche 718 Cayman S.

Remarkably, the M2 offers greater power and quicker acceleration from 0-62mph.

It’s projected to retain its residual value comparably well, akin to the Alpine A110 S while delivering fuel efficiency similar to its German sports car counterparts.

Is an M2 Expensive to Maintain?

Maintaining and repairing a BMW M2 comes with a cost that can vary. Estimated expenses span from $95 to $2331, with the average totaling around $330. It’s important to budget for regular maintenance and potential repairs to ensure the vehicle’s longevity and sustained performance.

Why Did BMW Discontinue the M2?

The outgoing BMW M2 faced discontinuation due to regulatory challenges. Specifically, it had to be removed from the European market ahead of schedule because it couldn’t meet the latest emissions standards.

This decision impacted sales, with the potential for even higher numbers if not for the emission-related constraints.

Franciscus van Meel, CEO of BMW M, the brand’s high-performance division, highlighted these emissions standards as a key factor behind the discontinuation.


In the realm of automotive choices, understanding the nuances and challenges associated with specific model years is crucial to making an informed decision.

This knowledge empowers you to approach your purchase with confidence, armed with insights into potential pitfalls and considerations.

Remember that thorough inspections, expert advice, and an understanding of the vehicle’s unique characteristics are your allies in the quest for the perfect BMW M2.

The key lies in your ability to approach the BMW M2 with awareness, steering clear of the “BMW M2 years to avoid” and embracing the years that align with your aspirations. By doing so, you embark on a journey that’s not just about the destination, but the exhilarating drive itself—a drive fueled by the power of knowledge and choice.