BMW M5 Years To Avoid (Best and Worst)

BMW M5 Years To Avoid – Welcome to the world of exhilarating performance, luxury, and the unmistakable allure of a BMW M5. As automotive enthusiasts, we understand the thrill that comes from driving a masterpiece that combines power, precision, and prestige.

However, not all years of the BMW M5 have been created equal, and there are some that stand out as ones to approach with caution.

In this guide, we’ll take you through the journey of BMW M5 years to avoid, shedding light on those moments when even the most prestigious badge encountered challenges.

When it comes to the BMW M5, its legacy is a blend of innovation and excellence. However, among the gems, a few years have emerged as the ones that didn’t quite live up to the reputation the M5 series has earned over the years.

BMW M5 Years To Avoid

So, let’s dive into the details and explore which BMW M5 years raised red flags and why, ensuring you make an informed choice and continue to revel in the sheer joy of driving a BMW M5.

BMW M5 Years To Avoid

When the thrill of the open road, precision engineering, and luxury converge, the BMW M5 stands as an embodiment of automotive excellence. As an avid BMW M5 enthusiast, your desire for the perfect ride is understandable.

Amidst the splendor of this iconic sports sedan, certain years have garnered a reputation as the less desirable choice.

From unexpected engine shutdowns to clutch cylinder issues, we unveil the reasons behind tagging 2012, 2013, 2014, 2015, and 2019 as the “worst years” for the BMW M5.

BMW M5 Years To Avoid

Let’s delve into these instances and understand why certain BMW M5 years have been labeled as “worst.”

2012-2014: An Array of Challenges

The years spanning from 2012 to 2014 marked a period when the BMW M5 encountered its fair share of issues. Among the common problems reported by owners were oil sensor malfunctions and unexpected engine shutdowns.

These occurrences not only disrupted the driving experience but also raised concerns about the overall reliability of these models.

Such issues tainted the reputation of an otherwise celebrated vehicle.

2015: Clutch Slave Cylinder Woes

In the year 2015, the BMW M5 faced a distinct challenge with the clutch slave cylinder. Owners reported troubles ranging from poor engagement to complete failure of the clutch mechanism.

This issue not only caused frustration but also hinted at potential design or manufacturing flaws within this model year.

As a result, the 2015 BMW M5 finds its place among the years to avoid.

2019: Striving for Improvement

While the 2019 BMW M5 showcased efforts to address the issues of its predecessors, it didn’t entirely escape the tag of being one of the less desirable years.

Owners reported comparatively fewer problems, but lingering concerns still cast a shadow over this model.

Although strides were made to enhance performance and reliability, some enthusiasts might opt for other years with a more proven track record.

BMW M5 Best Years

The BMW M5 – is the epitome of precision, power, and luxury. For enthusiasts and connoisseurs, identifying the cream of the crop among M5 models is an exhilarating journey.

We unveil the top years that have left an indelible mark on the legacy of the BMW M5.

Crafted with precision, praised for performance, and cherished by fans, these years represent the pinnacle of M5 engineering.

BMW M5 Best Years

Let’s explore exploring the best BMW M5 years according to the discerning eyes of experts and aficionados.

1998: A Masterpiece of Craftsmanship and Performance

At the forefront of the best BMW M5 years is the iconic 1998 model. Revered for its meticulous handmade build and exceptional driving dynamics, the ’98 M5 holds a special place in the hearts of enthusiasts.

This model exudes BMW’s commitment to artistry and performance. With a blend of handcrafted precision and cutting-edge engineering, the 1998 M5 showcases the essence of the M series.

Its legacy remains intact as a timeless representation of BMW’s dedication to crafting perfection.

2000: E39 M5 – A Marvel of Balance

The year 2000 introduced a marvel – the E39 M5. This iteration is hailed as one of the best years for the BMW M5.

Revered for its remarkable fusion of athleticism, opulence, and power, the E39 M5 remains an icon. Its 4.9-liter V8 engine is a symphony of power, while its handling and driving experience set a benchmark for the sports sedan category.

The E39 M5 epitomizes the harmonious balance between performance and luxury, etching its name in the annals of automotive history.

2005-2010: E60 M5 – Defying Convention

In the realm of innovation, the E60 M5 (2005-2010) emerges as a trailblazer. The standout feature of this model is its groundbreaking V10 engine, a departure from tradition that set the automotive world abuzz.

With exceptional power and performance, the E60 M5 redefined expectations.

Although it encountered challenges, its audacity to embrace change and offer a 6-speed manual transmission in the North American market endeared it to enthusiasts seeking a truly immersive driving experience.

BMW M5 Problems

The BMW M5, a symbol of power and precision, has been the dream of car enthusiasts for decades. However, like any complex machinery, it’s not immune to issues.

We delve into the realm of BMW M5 problems, shedding light on common issues while exploring the performance and reliability that define this iconic sports sedan.

BMW M5 Problems

From rod bearing concerns to the evolution of horsepower and transmission, we’ll equip you with the knowledge you need to keep your M5 running at its best.

1. Rod Bearing Problems

One common headache for BMW M5 owners is rod-bearing issues. If you hear knocking sounds from your engine’s bottom, it’s time to consult a professional mechanic. Regular oil analysis can help detect this problem early, preventing severe damage.

2. Throttle Actuator Issues

Throttle actuator problems might manifest as hesitation or surging while driving, accompanied by check engine lights and fault codes. Professional diagnosis is key to maintaining optimal performance.

3. Oil Consumption and Analysis

Some M5 models face oil consumption concerns. Monitor oil levels and perform oil analysis to catch potential problems before they escalate into costly repairs.

Read Also: Why Are BMW Oil Changes So Expensive?

4. Limp Mode and Fault Codes

Limp mode is a safety feature that triggers during critical issues. Your M5 might enter this mode due to low fuel, high oil temperatures, or fault codes. Promptly addressing the cause is essential to prevent long-term damage.

5. ABS Warning and Traction Control

If you encounter ABS warning or traction control lights, your Anti-lock Braking System or wheel speed sensors might be at fault. Professional attention is crucial for accurate diagnosis and resolution.

6. Tire Pressure Monitoring System

The TPMS ensures optimal tire pressure for safety and performance. React promptly to TPMS warnings by checking tire pressure and addressing issues.

BMW M5 Performance and Reliability Insights

Horsepower and Engine Variants

The M5 boasts impressive horsepower, with models like the 2020 M5 Competition offering a staggering 617 hp. Engine variations range from V10 engines in the E60 generation to the current V8 twin-turbo engines in the F90 generation.

Transmission and Gears

The transmission has evolved, with options including manual and automatic, depending on the model. The F90 M5 features an 8-speed automatic transmission for seamless shifting, while the F10 M5 utilizes a 7-speed dual-clutch transmission for precision.

Reliability Concerns

While the M5 is a performance marvel, there have been concerns, especially in turbocharged engine models from 2004-2015. However, proper maintenance can mitigate these issues, ensuring your M5 remains reliable.

Comparisons with M6 and M8

The M5 shares the spotlight with its siblings, the M6 and M8. While the M6 offers similar power, it’s tailored for grand touring. The M8 elevates both power and luxury but comes at a higher price point.

The BMW M5 strikes a remarkable balance between performance and practicality.

BMW M5 Competitors

In the world of high-performance luxury sedans, the BMW M5 reigns supreme. However, there are contenders that dare to challenge its dominance.

Let’s explore the landscape of BMW M5 competitors, examining models that offer similar thrills and alternatives for those seeking a unique driving experience.

BMW M5 Competitors

From the Audi RS7 to the Tesla Model S, each competitor presents a distinct blend of power, innovation, and luxury.

Let’s take a closer look at these contenders and explore their pros and cons.

Audi RS7: Power Meets Luxury

The Audi RS7 stands as a fierce competitor to the BMW M5. With its robust V8 engine, the RS7 delivers exhilarating acceleration and precision handling.

However, it’s important to note that certain Audi RS7 models might struggle with interior quality, falling short of the refinement found in the BMW M5.

While the RS7 offers a compelling driving experience, potential buyers should weigh its performance against the potential interior shortcomings.

Audi RS e-tron GT: Electrifying Alternative

For enthusiasts embracing the electric revolution, the Audi RS e-tron GT emerges as an intriguing alternative. This electric sports sedan combines rapid charging capabilities, a striking design, and a high-quality interior.

While the RS e-tron GT offers impressive technology and sustainability, it may not match the visceral driving experience of the BMW M5, which harnesses the power of a combustion engine.

Tesla Model S: Electric Powerhouse

The Tesla Model S is a titan in the electric vehicle realm and competes head-to-head with the BMW M5. Renowned for its incredible performance and advanced tech features, the Model S boasts impressive straight-line speed.

However, it’s important to consider that the driving dynamics and brand prestige associated with the M5 might not be fully replicated by the Model S.

As you explore Tesla’s offerings, be cautious of potential issues that some used models have encountered over time.

Cadillac CT5-V Blackwing: American Challenger

The Cadillac CT5-V Blackwing presents an American alternative to the BMW M5. Equipped with a supercharged V8 and track-capable performance, the CT5-V Blackwing is a force to be reckoned with.

However, it’s essential to note that its ride might not match the comfort of the M5, and its interior refinement may fall short of BMW’s standards.

While it offers impressive power, the Blackwing’s driving experience and interior comfort should be considered when comparing it to the M5.

Is a BMW M5 reliable?

The reliability of the BMW M5 can be a point of concern. According to extended warranty data provided by MotorEasy, the BMW 5 Series range, including the M5, has a poor reliability score of 26% as of December 2022.

This assessment covers both the current models (2017 onwards) and earlier generations of the 5 Series.

How many miles will the BMW M5 last?

Many BMW M5 owners report their vehicles lasting well beyond 100,000 miles with proper maintenance and care. For instance, with 75,000 miles on your M5, you have plans to keep it well past 100,000 miles.

Regular maintenance service intervals and vigilant monitoring of oil consumption are essential.

There are examples of M5s with over 100,000 miles still performing strongly, demonstrating the potential longevity of these vehicles when well-maintained.

Why are old M5s so expensive?

Older M5 models, particularly the E39 M5 from the last model year in 2003, are often expensive due to their rarity and collector appeal. For example, a low-mileage E39 M5 is a sought-after gem.

Collectors value ultra-low-mileage examples, making them desirable and driving up prices.

Enthusiasts and collectors alike recognize the historical significance and exceptional performance of these older M5 models, contributing to their premium price tags.

Is the BMW M5 expensive to maintain?

Maintaining a BMW M5 comes with a certain cost. The annual maintenance cost of a BMW M5 is estimated at $1,173. However, repair and maintenance expenses can vary based on factors like the vehicle’s age, mileage, location, and the shop you choose for servicing.

Proper budgeting for regular maintenance and potential repairs is essential for M5 owners to ensure the vehicle’s longevity and optimal performance.

Why is the BMW M5 famous?

The BMW M5’s fame is rooted in its status as an iconic performance sedan. Introduced in 1984 based on the E28 5 Series sedan, the M5 captured hearts with its blend of speed, power, and practicality.

It gained further recognition by using a modified version of the engine found in the legendary BMW M1 sports car.

The M5’s ability to balance high-performance capabilities with everyday usability and luxury cemented its reputation as a standout in the world of performance cars.


In the realm of high-performance luxury sedans, the BMW M5 stands tall as an emblem of power and precision.

As you embark on this decision-making journey, remember that the BMW M5 boasts its own legacy of power, innovation, and luxury.

The path you choose, be it the BMW M5 or its competitors, will define your driving experience and align with your desires.

By considering the key differences and similarities among these models, you’re equipped to make a choice that reflects your distinct automotive preferences.

In a world where options abound, the BMW M5’s legacy of excellence endures. As you explore alternatives and weigh your options, the BMW M5’s enduring allure continues to shine, guiding you toward a driving experience that’s second to none.