Tesla Model Y Years To Avoid (Best and Worst)

Tesla Model Y Years To Avoid – The Tesla Model Y has quickly gained popularity as a sleek and environmentally friendly SUV option. However, not all years of this vehicle are created equal. Before Tesla, electric cars were often seen as slow and impractical with limited range. However, Tesla changed that perception with the introduction of the high-performance Roadster, showing that electric cars could be both fun and practical.

In this blog post, we’ll take a closer look at the worst Tesla Model Y years to avoid and why they may not be the most reliable options for those looking to maintain a reliable vehicle.

tesla model y years to avoid

Let’s dive in and find the perfect Model Y for you.

Tesla Model Y Years To Avoid

Tesla Model Y’s reliability, there have been some concerns. This compact electric SUV has garnered numerous complaints and has been involved in multiple recalls.

That being said, if you’re in the market for a used Model Y, it’s important to know which years to avoid.

The worst Tesla Model Y years to steer clear of are the 2020 and 2021 models. These years have had the most reported issues and received low reliability scores.

2020 Tesla Model Y

The 2020 Tesla Model Y may not be the most reliable option, but it’s also not the worst. As with any first production year, there were some kinks to work out.

The 2020 Model Y received a low-reliability score of 2.0 out of 5.0 from Consumer Reports. One of the most reported issues with this model is the adaptive cruise control feature.

Some drivers experienced unexpected braking or the system failed to recognize certain obstacles. While these issues were not universally experienced, they did raise safety concerns.

Another problem that gained mainstream attention was the detaching steering wheel issue. Although these incidents may have been isolated or manufacturing defects, they caused alarm for owners.

While the 2020 Model Y may have some reliability issues, it is still worth considering if you can find one at a reasonable price.

tesla model y years to avoid

2021 Tesla Model Y

The 2021 Tesla Model Y is easily one of the worst years to avoid owning. According to CarProblemZoo, there have been a staggering 1,125 problems reported for the 2021 Model Y, making it the most complained-about model year of the SUV.

Unfortunately, it seems that the 2021 Model Y has struggled with the same issues as the debut model.

Consumer Reports gave the 2021 Tesla Model Y a reliability verdict score of 2.0 out of 5.0, but interestingly, it received a perfect owner satisfaction score of 5.0 out of 5.0.

This conflicting data suggests that while owners may love their Model Y, there are certainly some reliability issues to be aware of.

One of the major issues with the 2021 Model Y is related to its Forward Collision Avoidance system. Many drivers have reported problems with the Automatic Emergency Braking feature, often referred to as “phantom braking.”

This occurs when the vehicle suddenly slows down or stops abruptly, even when there is no obstacle in front of it.

These phantom brakes have been attributed to faulty sensors and software glitches.

While the 2021 Tesla Model Y may offer a satisfying ownership experience for some, the reported reliability issues, particularly with the Forward Collision Avoidance system, make it a year to avoid if you prioritize reliability.

Tesla Model Y Best Year

In the optimal year for the Tesla Model Y, prospective buyers often seek a balance between the latest advancements and the elimination of certain features found in newer models. Among the available options, the 2022 Tesla Model Y stands out as a frontrunner, especially in terms of performance and reliability.

tesla model y best year

The 2022 Tesla Model Y: The Sweet Spot

The 2022 iteration of the Tesla Model Y is widely regarded as the best-year model, striking a harmonious balance between incorporating the latest features and refining existing ones.

Tesla made pivotal enhancements to the Model Y in 2022, addressing previous iterations’ shortcomings while introducing innovations that set it apart in the competitive electric SUV market.

Performance Excellence of the 2022 Model Y

For those prioritizing performance, the 2022 Tesla Model Y Performance variant shines as a standout choice. Industry consensus positions this model year as the pinnacle of Tesla’s engineering prowess, combining high-performance capabilities with improved reliability.

Reliability and Continuous Improvement: Tesla’s commitment to iterative improvements is evident in the 2022 Model Y. While no vehicle is entirely free from potential issues, the 2022 model demonstrates superior reliability compared to its predecessors, showcasing Tesla’s dedication to refining their offerings over time.

Range and Safety Features

The Tesla Model Y, particularly in its Long Range variant, boasts one of the most impressive ranges among electric vehicles.

With a remarkable 330 miles of range, the 2022 Model Y addresses the range anxiety concern prevalent in the EV market, offering an ideal solution for long-distance travel without frequent charging stops.

Safety and Autopilot: Beyond its impressive range, the Model Y excels in safety features, having performed admirably in various safety tests. Equipped with Tesla’s suite of driver-assistance features, known as Autopilot, the 2022 iteration delivers an added layer of safety and convenience for drivers.

2023 Tesla Model Y: A Promising Successor

tesla model y best year

While the 2022 Model Y stands as the epitome of Tesla’s innovation and refinement, the 2023 iteration is poised to continue this legacy.

Although details may vary between the 2022 and 2023 models, the latter builds upon the foundation laid by its predecessor, potentially incorporating further enhancements and improvements.

The selection narrows down to two prime choices in today’s market: the 2022 and 2023 Tesla Model Y. These model years represent Tesla’s ongoing commitment to advancement, providing prospective buyers with options that reflect the culmination of years of development and refinement.

The Newer, The Better: With the Tesla Model Y, the general rule applies—newer iterations tend to embody the latest updates and improvements. Both the 2022 and 2023 models showcase Tesla’s dedication to rectifying past errors and introducing innovations, akin to a continuously updated video game system.

When seeking the most reliable and technologically advanced Tesla Model Y, the 2022 and 2023 iterations stand tall as prime choices, embodying Tesla’s commitment to continual improvement and customer satisfaction.

Tesla Model Y Problems

Every vehicle, regardless of its make or model, can encounter issues that demand attention. The Tesla Model Y, a marvel of electric engineering, isn’t exempt from experiencing certain recurring problems.

Understanding and identifying these issues can empower owners to address them proactively.

Here, we delve into some of the prevalent problems reported in the Tesla Model Y across various model years.

Common Tesla Model Y Problems

Common Tesla Model Y Problems: Identified Concerns

Motorandwheels.com has highlighted several recurring issues that Tesla Model Y owners should be vigilant about. These problems, while not universal, have been reported by some drivers and merit attention:

Touchscreen Troubles

One of the primary concerns reported involves touchscreen malfunctions. Instances of unresponsive or erratic behavior from the central touchscreen interface have been documented.

As this interface controls numerous vehicle functionalities, any glitches in its operation can significantly impact the overall user experience.

Charging Errors

Issues related to charging, such as errors during the charging process or inconsistencies in charging performance, have been reported by some Model Y owners.

Charging-related problems can potentially disrupt the vehicle’s usability and require immediate attention for efficient charging functionality.

Unexpected Alarm Activation

Sporadic instances of the vehicle alarm going off unexpectedly have been noted. While infrequent, these instances can be disruptive and potentially inconvenient for owners and those in proximity to the vehicle.

Braking Faults

Reports of braking faults or anomalies have surfaced among some Tesla Model Y owners. Any issues related to braking systems can significantly compromise vehicle safety and warrant immediate inspection and resolution.

Suspension Errors

Instances of suspension-related errors or inconsistencies have been reported, impacting the vehicle’s ride quality and handling. Addressing suspension issues promptly is crucial for ensuring a smooth and safe driving experience.

Recognizing these potential problems can aid owners in adopting a proactive approach toward vehicle maintenance and troubleshooting. Timely identification and resolution of these issues can prevent inconveniences and sudden visits to repair facilities.

Is Tesla Model Y Reliable?

The reliability of the Tesla Model Y has been a topic of discussion since its release. While the Model Y hasn’t been on the market for a long time, its recent years have garnered attention.

According to cars.usnews.com, the Model Y receives a predicted reliability score of 73/100, which is not the worst but falls short of being ideal.

It ranks ninth out of fourteen competing models in terms of reliability, according to motorbiscuit.com. So, while the Tesla Model Y offers a sleek driving experience, it may not be the most reliable option in the electric car market.

Is Tesla Model Y Expensive To Maintain?

Maintaining a Tesla Model Y can be quite expensive compared to other vehicles. According to automoblog.com, the annual cost to keep a typical Tesla in top shape ranges from $587 to $832, which is around the average for a vehicle.

However, the specialized nature of the Model Y means that if you do encounter any issues, the repairs can be on the pricier side.

While a standard Tesla rarely experiences problems, it’s important to be prepared for potentially costly fixes when it comes to the Model Y.

Despite this, the reliability of the Tesla Model Y makes it a worthwhile investment for many.

Is Tesla Y considered a luxury?

When it comes to luxury SUVs, the Tesla Model Y is definitely in the conversation. While it may not have all the bells and whistles of some high-end luxury brands, the Model Y offers a sleek and stylish design that is sure to turn heads.

The Long Range model, in particular, provides a luxurious driving experience with its comfortable interior and advanced features.

Although it may be less expensive than the Performance model, it still falls within the pricing range of other luxury SUVs.

Why is the Tesla Model Y so cheap?

As consumers become increasingly concerned about the environment and look for electric options, the affordability of the Tesla Model Y may come as a surprise. The reason behind the Model Y’s competitive price tag lies in economies of scale.

Tesla has been able to achieve significant economies of scale, especially with the Model Y, by producing a large volume of vehicles.

This high production volume allows Tesla to reduce the cost per unit, ultimately making the Model Y more affordable for consumers. If you’re wondering why the Model Y is so cheap, it’s all thanks to Tesla’s successful implementation of economies of scale.

Does Tesla Y have good resale value?

The resale value of the Tesla Model Y, you’ll be happy to know that it’s one of the best in its class. According to a German study, the Model Y has the highest residual value among electric vehicles.

After four years of ownership, the car retains an impressive 64% of its original value, which is the highest among all models.

This speaks to the reliability and desirability of the Model Y, making it a great investment for those looking for a vehicle with strong resale value.

What are the negatives of the Tesla Model Y?

There are some pros and cons to consider. On the positive side, this electric SUV offers a spacious interior, impressive driving range, and exhilarating acceleration. However, it’s important to acknowledge the negatives as well. The Model Y features an overly digital interior, which may not appeal to everyone.

There have also been reports of build quality issues, such as inconsistent panel gaps and uneven paint application.

Additionally, some drivers have found the handling of the Model Y to be clumsy compared to other vehicles in its category.


In the realm of electric vehicles, Tesla stands at the forefront, reshaping perceptions and driving innovation. The Model Y, a testament to Tesla’s commitment to sustainability and technological advancement, offers consumers an enticing all-electric SUV option.

In navigating the landscape of used Tesla Model Ys, an informed approach that weighs the strengths and weaknesses of different model years can empower buyers to make a confident and rewarding investment.

By understanding the nuances between various Model Y iterations, prospective buyers can confidently navigate the used Tesla Model Y years to avoid, ensuring a purchase that aligns with their expectations and delivers a fulfilling ownership experience.

Related Articles About TESLA: