Toyota 86 Years To Avoid (Best and Worst)

Toyota 86 Years To Avoid – The Toyota 86, a product of the synergistic collaboration between Toyota and Subaru in 2012, quickly distinguished itself in the compact sports car domain. As a competitively priced, performance-driven car, the 86 robustly vies with heavyweights like the Mazda Miata.

The 86, with its 2+2 seating arrangement, has earned kudos for its agile handling, immediate responsiveness, and driver-focused design ethos.

At the core of the Toyota 86 rests a lively 2.0-liter four-cylinder engine, producing a remarkable 205 horsepower and 156 lb-ft of torque in its manual transmission variant, promising drivers a thrilling ride.

For automatic transmission enthusiasts, an alternate model caters to a spectrum of driving predilections.

Toyota 86 Years To Avoid

The 86’s rear-wheel-drive setup, bucking the front-wheel-drive trend common to its class, coupled with its lightweight construction and low center of gravity, significantly boosts the vehicle’s nimbleness, ensuring a responsive and gripping driving experience for aficionados.

Externally, the Toyota 86 showcases a streamlined, aerodynamic contour, hinting at its dynamic capabilities while radiating a sporty charm.

The interior, designed with the driver at its heart, features sporty seats that offer both comfort and support during spirited drives.

A leather-wrapped steering wheel and a collection of tech features amplify the driver-focused cockpit, enhancing aesthetics and functionality.

Toyota’s celebrated reputation for reliability is evident in the 86. As a compact sports car, the Toyota 86 has proven its reliability consistently. Its dependable performance, together with Toyota’s commitment to engineering precision, has established the 86 as a trustworthy option in the sports car arena.

Toyota 86 Years To Avoid

Our analysis shows a higher incidence of reported issues with this model compared to others in the lineup, even though detailed data is sparse. Complaints range from engine performance to transmission problems and electrical glitches.

As a result, used car buyers might want to bypass the 2019 Toyota 86 to avoid potential reliability and performance-related issues.

The data from iSeeCars, which ranks Toyota as the most reliable car brand with an impressive 2.3% of Toyota models reaching the milestone of 200,000 miles, underscores the brand’s commitment to longevity and durability.

However, even within the otherwise stellar track record of the Toyota 86 lineup, there exists a model year that potential buyers may want to approach with caution.

2019 Toyota 86

While the Toyota 86 series, being relatively new in Toyota’s lineup, boasts a commendable track record for reliability, our analysis has identified the 2019 model year as one that raises concerns.

Despite the limited data available due to the car’s recent introduction, our research has unearthed a higher incidence of reported issues and complaints associated with the 2019 Toyota 86 compared to other model years within the lineup.

The specifics surrounding the issues plaguing the 2019 Toyota 86 remain somewhat elusive due to the scarcity of comprehensive data.

However, the reported complaints suggest various problems that have surfaced, potentially compromising the overall driving experience and reliability of this particular model year.

Areas of Reported Concerns:

  1. Engine Performance: Some owners have cited issues related to engine performance, including concerns about power delivery and overall engine reliability.
  2. Transmission Problems: Instances of transmission-related issues, such as erratic shifting or mechanical faults, have been noted by a portion of 2019 Toyota 86 owners.
  3. Electrical Glitches: Complaints regarding electrical systems and components have also emerged, signaling potential problems with the car’s electronic functionalities.

Based on the available data and reported issues, the 2019 Toyota 86 emerges as a model year that used car buyers may consider avoiding to mitigate the risk of encountering reliability and performance-related issues.

Read Also: Toyota CHR Years To Avoid

Toyota 86 Best Years

Affordable sports cars captivate driving enthusiasts seeking the thrill of high-performance vehicles without the hefty price tag associated with luxury cars.

Toyota 86 Best Years

Known for its engaging handling, sleek design, and impressive performance, the Toyota 86 has steadily gained acclaim in a competitive segment.

For enthusiasts eyeing reliability and performance, navigating the Toyota 86 lineup requires an understanding of each model year’s nuances.

Let’s delve into the years that stand out as the most reliable options for prospective buyers:

2017 Toyota 86

Toyota 86 Best Years

Despite some reported issues related to the key interlock function and spare tire air pressure, the 2017 Toyota 86 remains a reliable and value-oriented choice.

Though consumer reviews mentioned concerns about clutch sensitivity and brake response, it received an admirable 4.7-star rating out of 5.0, making it a credible option in the lineup.

2018 Toyota 86

Toyota 86 Best Years

The 2018 Toyota 86 stands as another commendable choice within the lineup. While a recall regarding the low-pressure fuel pump was noted, reports of significant issues remain scarce.

This model year, praised for being an affordable “driver’s car,” shows promise in terms of reliability and performance.

Read Also: Toyota Mirai Years To Avoid

2020 Toyota 86

Toyota 86 Best Years

The 2020 Toyota 86 garnered positive reviews, with no reported recalls or complaints to date.

While praised for its handling and build quality, some critiques surfaced regarding its engine performance, torque delivery, and deficiencies in safety features and infotainment systems.

2022 Toyota 86

Toyota 86 Best Years

The latest iteration of the Toyota 86, the 2022 model year, signifies a leap in performance with the introduction of a 2.4-liter flat-four engine.

This revamped powertrain offers increased horsepower and torque, earning accolades from reputable sources such as Car and Driver, receiving a perfect rating and an Editor’s Choice award.

Despite its relatively recent release, the 2022 Toyota 86 exhibits promising enhancements in power and potential reliability.

Determining the “best” Toyota 86 years depends on the buyer’s priorities—be it a balance between reliability and value or an inclination towards cutting-edge performance enhancements.

Toyota 86 Problems

The Toyota 86, celebrated for its sporty demeanor and engaging performance, has encountered some reported issues that merit attention from prospective buyers and owners alike.

These concerns, while not pervasive, shed light on specific areas that warrant consideration.

Toyota 86 Problems

Reported Problems with the 2019 Toyota 86

CARHP delineated several concerns specifically linked to the 2019 Toyota 86, signaling potential reliability issues that some owners have faced.

These issues encompass various aspects, including engine and mechanical complications, fuel/propulsion system glitches, brake deterioration, safety concerns, and dashboard electrical anomalies.

  • Engine and Mechanical Complaints: Owners reported instances of unsteady engine revs due to ECU encoding errors, resulting in rough idling and misfires.
  • Fuel/Propulsion System Issues: Reports surfaced regarding unexpected fuel pump failures leading to potential engine stalling, thereby posing safety hazards while driving.
  • Service Brakes Deterioration: The front brake pads on the 2019 Toyota 86 showed signs of wearing faster than the rear brake pads, potentially affecting braking performance.
  • Safety-related Concerns: Incidents involving seat belt releases upon impact during collisions led to injuries for both the driver and passengers, indicating potential safety flaws.
  • Dashboard Electrical System Anomalies: Owners experienced dashboard lights flickering, water leakage from the dash, and in a severe case, an electrical issue behind the steering wheel causing a fire hazard.

Despite Toyota’s well-established track record for reliability, user feedback and complaints highlight specific incidents and concerns related to the 2019 Toyota 86.

The National Highway Traffic Safety Administration (NHTSA) reported a mere six complaints and one recall for this model year, focusing on issues encompassing the electrical system, engine, fuel/propulsion system, service brakes, and vehicle speed control.

  • A serious incident involving a dashboard electrical issue resulted in a car fire despite dealership assurances.
  • Collision-related seat belt releases cause injuries to occupants.
  • Mixed user feedback: While some users reported no significant issues, others mentioned isolated incidents such as a fuel pump malfunction.

Additionally, feedback from a Reddit user highlighted relatively smooth ownership with a few minor issues, suggesting the 2016+ models as more reliable.

Are Toyota GT86 reliable?

According to our Driver Power survey, the GT86 isn’t ranked as the most reliable Toyota. However, it’s important to note that despite this ranking, Toyota generally has a reputation for producing dependable cars.

Although the GT86 is manufactured by Subaru, it remains under the Toyota brand.

Is a GR86 good?

Yes, the 2024 GR86 is highly regarded as an excellent sports car. Its driving dynamics are described as pure, offering exceptional handling and responsiveness. While it might not outpace some muscle cars in drag races, its power is deemed adequate, delivering an exhilarating driving experience.

Can you daily drive a Toyota 86?

Many drivers find the Toyota 86 to be an ideal option for a sportier daily driving experience. It’s relatively affordable and enjoyable to drive daily. Despite having a small gas tank, it manages to offer decent mileage for a sports car.

How much is an oil change for a Toyota 86?

For the 2022 Toyota GR86, the cost of an oil change is estimated to range between $117 to $127. Routine oil changes are essential, recommended every 7,500 to 10,000 miles or every 6 to 12 months to ensure proper maintenance.

Is the Toyota 86 a good used car?

The Toyota 86, based on a personal ownership experience with a GTS 86 automatic variant since 2014, is praised as a fantastic car. It’s been reliable, displaying exceptional performance, handling, and cost-effectiveness.

The overall consensus is that it’s a visually appealing, well-handling, economical, and enjoyable vehicle.

Why do people like GR86?

Despite minor drawbacks such as engine limitations, a less-than-ideal driving position, and a basic interior, the GR86 shines due to its exceptional chassis. It’s praised for offering one of the best handling experiences among new cars currently available in the market, making it a standout choice for handling prowess regardless of its price range.


The Toyota 86 offers an alluring mix of performance, affordability, and dependability that enthralls many enthusiasts. However, the 2019 model year raises eyebrows.

For those considering this sporty gem, it’s key to diligently investigate potential reliability issues of certain model years, ensuring their thrilling drive doesn’t come with unwelcome surprises.

This makes looking into the “Toyota 86 years to avoid” absolutely crucial. Comprehensive knowledge about the Toyota 86 reliability would give potential owners a clearer picture of what to expect.

Related Articles: