Why Are BMW 5 Series So Cheap? Let’s Find Out

Why Are BMW 5 Series So Cheap – When it comes to luxury cars, BMW has long been a symbol of prestige, engineering excellence, and unparalleled driving experience.

Among its renowned lineup, the BMW 5 Series stands out as a beacon of sophistication, combining performance, comfort, and cutting-edge technology.

However, some astute car enthusiasts may wonder: Why are BMW 5 Series so cheap compared to its counterparts in the luxury car segment?

In this article, we’ll explore the intriguing world of the BMW 5 Series and uncover the factors that contribute to its relatively affordable price tag.

Why Are BMW 5 Series So Cheap

From production techniques to market dynamics, we’ll shed light on the aspects that set the 5 Series apart in terms of affordability without compromising on the hallmark BMW quality.

Reason Why Are BMW 5 Series So Cheap?

If you’ve ever wondered why BMW 5 Series cars seem to be more affordable compared to other luxury vehicles, you’re not alone.

The BMW 5 Series, known for its blend of performance, style, and comfort, has become a go-to choice for many, especially among younger enthusiasts in Europe.

However, there’s a catch – these cars tend to become money pits as they age.

Let’s explore the reasons behind the apparent affordability of BMW 5 Series cars and why they might not be as cheap as they seem.

Why Are BMW 5 Series So Cheap

1. The Young Enthusiast Factor

One of the reasons BMW 5 Series cars appear to be more affordable is that they are a status symbol for younger buyers in Europe.

Just as big pickups or muscle cars hold sway in the U.S., young European enthusiasts often gravitate towards the BMW 3 and 5 Series, Mercedes C and E Class, or Audi A4 and A6.

These cars represent a sense of achievement and style, making them popular choices among this demographic.

Read Also: BMW 5 Series Years To Avoid

2. Initial Costs vs. Long-Term Expenses

While the initial purchase price of a used BMW 5 Series may seem attractive, it’s essential to consider the long-term ownership costs.

A 5 Series BMW with a full history and maintenance book isn’t necessarily cheap. This is especially true if you’re looking at newer models with lower mileage.

Take, for example, the experience of a BMW owner who bought a 2012 BMW 5 Series with relatively low mileage.

The car was in pristine condition at the time of purchase.

However, within a few months, a series of expensive repairs began to surface.

From front and rear suspension issues to sunroof problems, air conditioning radiator failures, and even electronic components like touch sensor door handles, the list of repairs kept growing.

In just four years, the owner had to spend a significant sum on maintenance, highlighting a common issue with aging BMWs.

Read Also: Why Are Used BMWs So Cheap?

3. The German Luxury Car Paradox

German luxury cars, including BMWs, tend to become money pits once they reach a certain age or mileage.

This phenomenon is not limited to the BMW 5 Series but extends to other models like the Mercedes S-Class and BMW 7 Series.

Once these cars are out of warranty, the cost of repairs can often exceed the initial purchase price, making ownership a financially challenging endeavor.

4. The 3 Series vs. the 5 Series

The BMW 3 Series is often favored for its handling capabilities and sportier driving experience. It’s perceived as a more straightforward, less electronically complex vehicle.

In contrast, the 5 Series offers a more refined driving experience, but it comes with a longer wheelbase and a heavier chassis, making it less sporty.

If you’re seeking a refined German car with a plethora of features, you might opt for a Mercedes E-Class over a BMW 5 Series.

Read Also: Why Are BMW So Unreliable?

5. The Reality of Out-of-Warranty BMWs

As a former BMW employee points out, most BMWs with expired warranties become money pits.

Repair bills can easily reach five figures, making ownership financially draining.

If you’re prepared to spend $25,000 on a low-mileage, four-year-old 5 Series, be aware that you might need to invest an additional $10,000 in repairs shortly after purchase.

6. The Reliability Factor

Why Are BMW 5 Series So Cheap

BMW’s reputation for reliability has faced scrutiny, with frequent reports of issues ranging from ball joints and bushings to oil and coolant leaks, climate control problems, electronic failures, and even internal engine failure.

In contrast, brands like Lexus offer more straightforward ownership experiences with fewer surprises.

Is the BMW 5 Series a reliable car?

According to Consumer Reports, the 5 Series generally has a reputation for high build quality and reliability, but there have been some problematic model years, including 2011, 2012, 2013, and 2018.

Is a BMW 5 Series affordable?

While buying a new 5 Series can be expensive, opting for a used one allows you to experience the BMW brand at a more affordable price point.

Why is the BMW 5 Series so popular?

The BMW 5 Series has gained popularity worldwide due to its enhanced intelligence, striking design, and improved fuel efficiency. It has consistently dominated the premium Business Sedan segment globally.

Is BMW 5 expensive to maintain?

The maintenance and repair costs for a BMW 5 Series are estimated to be around $13,530 for the first decade of service. This is slightly higher than the industry average for luxury sedan models, with a 40.39% chance of requiring a major repair during that period.

Did BMW discontinue the 5 Series?

The current-generation BMW 5 Series is approaching the end of its lifecycle, with the next-generation version scheduled to make its global debut on May 24, 2023.

Is the BMW 5 Series fun to drive?

Both the 3 Series and 5 Series are known for providing an enjoyable driving experience, as expected from BMW models. They perform well and offer a satisfying driving dynamic.


The allure of the BMW 5 Series’s apparent affordability often masks a deeper reality. While these cars may be initially enticing, especially for younger enthusiasts, it’s crucial to consider the long-term ownership costs.

The tales of expensive repairs and maintenance are not uncommon, particularly once these vehicles age and fall out of warranty.

This pattern is not unique to the 5 Series but extends to other luxury German cars as well.

The affordability of BMW 5 Series cars can be deceiving. While the initial purchase price may seem attractive, it’s crucial to consider the long-term costs associated with owning an aging BMW.

These cars often require substantial maintenance and repair expenses, which can outweigh their initial affordability.

So, when pondering, “Why Are BMW 5 Series So Cheap?”, it’s imperative to recognize the complexities that underlie their seemingly accessible price point.

Related Articles: